The Smokin' Puffin

The Smokin' Puffin is the kind of small, slightly chaotic pub that thrives on personality. Located just off Reykjavik's harbour on Hafnarstraeti, it occupies a compact space that gets loud, warm, and convivial the moment more than a dozen people walk in — which, on most evenings, happens early and stays that way until closing.

The Drinks

The bar stocks a decent range of Icelandic beers alongside imported spirits and a cocktail list that includes the "Choco Puffin" — a house speciality that leans sweet and is ordered more often than any regular will publicly admit. The beer selection covers the main Icelandic craft breweries, and the staff are happy to recommend something if you are unfamiliar with the local options.

Prices are standard for downtown Reykjavik, which means expensive by any international standard. Happy hour, when running, takes some of the sting out. Time your arrival accordingly.

The Atmosphere

This is where The Smokin' Puffin distinguishes itself. The venue is small enough that anonymity is impossible — you will make eye contact with everyone, overhear conversations from every corner, and almost certainly end up talking to someone you did not arrive with. On karaoke nights, the entire bar becomes the audience. On live music nights, the musicians are close enough to touch.

The staff contribute significantly to the atmosphere. Multiple reviewers single out the friendliness and energy of the bar team, and there is a warmth to the welcome that feels genuine rather than professional.

The Puffin Question

Yes, they serve puffin. The smoked puffin breast is on the menu, and it is one of the more accessible places in Reykjavik to try the bird if you are so inclined. Puffin is traditional Icelandic food, though its presence on tourist menus is controversial. The choice is yours.

Practical Tips

Best nights. Friday and Saturday for the full experience — live music or karaoke, a packed house, and the kind of energy that makes small pubs special. Weeknights are quieter and better for actual conversation.

Arrive early. The space is small and fills up. Getting there by early evening means you secure a seat; arriving at 23:00 on a Saturday means you stand.

Location. Hafnarstraeti 4 is central and easy to find. The harbour is a one-minute walk in one direction, Laugavegur a two-minute walk in the other.

Solo travellers. This is one of the better bars in Reykjavik for people travelling alone. The size and the atmosphere make it easy to fall into conversation, and the staff are good at making solo visitors feel included.

The Smokin' Puffin is not trying to be a craft cocktail bar or a gastro pub. It is a pub, full stop — small, loud, and welcoming. For an evening that feels spontaneous and social rather than curated and Instagram-ready, it is one of the better choices on the Reykjavik pub circuit.